2023 Elections: 1,209 Petitions Filed, Only 103 Succeeded, Retired Justice Raised Alarm Over Electoral Litigation

2023 Elections: 1,209 Petitions Filed, Only 103 Succeeded, Retired Justice Raised Alarm Over Electoral Litigation

- in LEGAL AND JUDICIARY
74
0

Lagos, Nigeria — Nigerian courts must adopt a more interventionist approach to electoral disputes, particularly cases involving violations of political parties’ constitutions, unlawful candidate substitutions, and internal party manipulation, a retired Court of Appeal Justice has declared.

Justice Oludotun Adefope-Okojie made the call on Tuesday while delivering the 2026 annual lecture organised by Gavel International in collaboration with the Ernest Sisei Ikoli Foundation at the Lagos Chamber of Commerce and Industry, Alausa, Ikeja, Lagos.

Speaking on the theme ‘Electoral Process in Nigeria: Managing the Boundaries of Judicial Intervention,’ the retired appellate judge expressed concern that Nigeria’s electoral process has increasingly shifted from polling units to courtrooms, with courts frequently determining election winners instead of the electorate.

Justice Adefope-Okojie revealed that 1,209 petitions were filed following the 2023 general elections against 1,280 contested offices, approximately 94.5 petitions for every 100 contested seats.

In comparison, she said, Kenya recorded about 20.6 petitions per 100 seats in 2017 and 6.5 in 2022, while Ghana recorded approximately 5.8 petitions per 100 contested parliamentary seats in 2020.

The judge disclosed that only 103 of the 1,209 petitions filed after the 2023 elections succeeded, arguing that the high volume of litigation had not translated into corresponding electoral justice.

“This is an aberration,” she declared, noting that the figures reflect a serious deficit of public confidence in Nigeria’s electoral process.

The retired justice blamed political parties for contributing to the problem through their inability to comply with their constitutions when selecting candidates.

She identified flawed congresses, unlawful substitutions, imposition of preferred candidates, ballot snatching, vote buying, rigging, manipulation, and falsification of election results as key irregularities driving the surge in election petitions.

The jury called on the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) to discharge its responsibilities impartially and urged political parties to respect their constitutions and adhere strictly to established procedures for candidate selection.

In his intervention, Lagos-based Senior Advocate of Nigeria (SAN) Femi Falana called for comprehensive reforms of Nigeria’s electoral and judicial systems, warning that the manipulation of election outcomes through court judgments poses a serious threat to democracy.

Falana urged the media, judiciary, political parties, and civil society organisations to intensify efforts to combat electoral malpractice, political impunity, and violence ahead of future elections. He insisted that Nigeria must stop sacrificing justice on the altar of technicalities.

The SAN expressed concern that controversial electoral judgments had exposed the judiciary, particularly the Supreme Court, to public ridicule and weakened confidence in the country’s electoral process.

The chairman of the occasion, Chief Anthony George-Ikoli (SAN), observed that Nigerian elections are increasingly being decided in courtrooms rather than at polling units.

He noted that the development had popularised the expression “victory in the courtroom,” reflecting the growing perception that winning at the polling unit is no longer sufficient to secure political office.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may also like

Dangote Cement Cuts Road Accidents by 60% with Driver Safety Program

Lagos, Nigeria – Dangote Cement Plc has announced